Friday, November 30, 2012

Three Loves: Three Losses by Phillip Hoyle


I tell of Ted, Michael, and Rafael.

I tell of Kaposi’s sarcoma, Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma, and Hepatitis C.

I tell of the loving effects of all on me.

Ted’s illness eventually became the focus of my relationship to him, a kind of maturing friendship that clarified my need to take care of another person who was dying. I wanted to attend to him at the end of his life and realized I’d willingly take a leave of absence from work to do so. This seemed a great change for me. It also clarified my anger at the church and society for their often callus response to gay folk in general and specifically to those living with and dying from HIV-related diseases. It seemed that in our society to debate long-held fears was more important than to support people—the real places of life and death.

I found meaning as well as satisfaction in letting Ted teach me more about the issues and about myself before his death. The last time we were together—a several-day stay at his home in San Francisco—we visited San Francisco General Hospital, and I walked around Pacific Heights while he met with his psychiatrist. We heard Beethoven’s “Missa Solemnis” together, and he taught me how to smoke marijuana.  He told me that when his KS lesions so distressed him, he complained to his HIV physician. “I just can’t stand to look at them.”

“Then don’t,” she responded. “Wear long pants.”

Ted wore long pants but was not doing well on that last visit. I wanted to return to be with him. Although I volunteered, I wasn’t called in at the end, which frustrated me. Still, I was able to attend his memorial service, an experience of balloons, tributes, music, and love.

After I moved to Denver I gave massages at Colorado AIDS Project as a kind of memorial to my long-time friend Ted. There I met Michael, a man who came to me for massage. I noticed that he was noticing me. He wanted more massage. When later he came to my home studio to receive one, I was pleased and served tea at the end of the session. Then he wanted more than massage. We began seeing each other socially. Of course, I knew he was HIV positive. What I didn’t know was that he was losing weight rapidly and that his numbers were going in the wrong directions. When I realized these distressing trends, I suggested that at his next medical appointment he show the swollen lymph nodes in his neck and groin and insist that someone touch them. He did so and the tests that ensued pinpointed non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma. I started spending most nights at his place when he started chemotherapy and discovered just how much I had come to love him in our short time together. As he sickened I did more and more of his yard and housework. I wanted him to be comfortable and I wanted to enjoy his company.

Michael taught me some rather genteel approaches to breakfast, to eating out, and to living with another man. I was an avid learner. He also was the occasion for me to see the down side of some gay relationships particularly as relates to family complications. When his brother and elderly mother were coming to see him after his chemotherapy had to be discontinued, he asked me to move back to my apartment during their stay. I was confused but also realized we are what we are: he was who he was, I was who I was, both imperfect when coping with the extremities of life. I made sure I dropped by to meet his family, to be for them one of Michael’s friends. I never knew what they understood of our relationship.

I did for Michael in his last weeks what I couldn’t do for Ted: made him comfortable, showered him with my love, sat by him while he took his final breaths. My sadness mixed with love at his death. I was so pleased that I had cleaned up after him, prepared his food, and loved him in the most practical ways possible—the work of family and of gay lovers in the face of AIDS. In it all, I came to appreciate the effective work of Denver Health’s clinics and staff. I appreciated the attentions of other friends of this lover of mine. His memorial service brought together a wide variety of folk who celebrated his life, friendships, and love.

Some months later I met Rafael at a bus stop. We talked; we liked each other. Eventually we got together after a frustrating courtship characterized by my wondering where this cute man was. We came together with an emotional intensity that surely would have entertained both Ted and Michael and that surprised me. It also thrilled me to my innermost gay self that I was still discovering.

Rafael told me he was HIV positive some weeks into this intense relationship. I said that was fine and told him about Ted and Michael. We set up housekeeping, but in a few weeks he was growing ill. He too was a client at the Infectious Diseases Clinic at Denver Health. I warned him I might cry when we went there because of my memories of going to the same kind of appointments with Michael.

I felt somewhat like a veteran and told him I wanted to meet his family before he ended up in the hospital. That didn’t happen. I met his brother in his room at Denver Health. Later I met his parents and sister at the same place. I stood by him and helped his family as his illness worsened. We waited during a surgery on his aorta, made visits to the Intensive Care Unit, the Intensive Care Step-down Unit, and other floors where he was treated. Finally, a diagnosis of full-term hepatitis C emerged. Two weeks later, after a one-day home hospice attempt, the Hospice of St. John took him in. There he died.

I liked that at the end he was surrounded by family. I was pleased to be included. He had told his parents they’d not be welcome in our home if they in any way excluded me. This frail man of indomitable spirit took care of me with his family as I took care of his daily needs. Our love’s intensity sustained and wrecked us both at the end. I let go gently, deeply saddened, and with startlingly grateful respect for this man’s life and death. But I was also afraid of the effect the loss of such an intense relationship would bring. The resulting low I experienced was as intense as the heights of the love we shared. I survived. I felt as if Saints Ted and Michael attended me in my adoration of the beautiful and strong Rafael.

This awful disease with all its science, social ramifications, and family trauma and drama continues to affect my life daily. Friends and clients still live and die with its effects. Memories seared deeply into my brain and body accompany my every move. I continue to hate the disease while I love those with it, both past and present. 


About the Author


 Phillip Hoyle lives in Denver and spends his time writing, painting, giving massages, and socializing. His massage practice funds his other activities that keep him busy with groups of writers and artists, and folk with pains. Following thirty-two years in church work, he now focuses on creating beauty and ministering to the clients in his practice. He volunteers at The Center leading “Telling Your Story.”

No comments:

Post a Comment